Last night I finished reading Bringing Down the House. Overall, the story was good and the writing was horrible. I kept feeling that I was reading a thinly veiled management book that was used for demonstrating the fundamentals of lean manufacturing or some such thing (The Goal is a glaring example of this genre). The other thing was the author, who has seemed to do a bit of research on MIT made a couple glaring mistakes:
As I wrote in my reading journal, I am not surprised any more by the things that MIT students get involved in, so the story was just interesting as entertainment. I wish, though, that the kid who was being profiled had written it. I'm sure he could have done a much better job (since he's a graduate, he must have passed Phase II) then the author
- Students do not graduate "with honors" in the standard sense from MIT (I mentioned that the author kept saying a student in the book graduated with honors to a fellow MIT alum. Her response: "You can't do that."
- The Harvard Bridge was referred to as the Mass Ave. Bridge (At least he didn't call it the Massachusetts Avenue Bridge)
- The students referred to the Infinate as the Infinate Corridor (Something that was rarely done if a student was beyond his freshman year)
As I wrote in my reading journal, I am not surprised any more by the things that MIT students get involved in, so the story was just interesting as entertainment. I wish, though, that the kid who was being profiled had written it. I'm sure he could have done a much better job (since he's a graduate, he must have passed Phase II) then the author
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home